LifeWay Profits
I am not impressed by the amount LifeWay “gives back” to the Cooperative Program. My church budget is dwindling through increasingly higher priced materials that are increasingly not applicable to my small church situation. Don’t get me started on the insane shipping and handling fee structure. LifeWay privileges large churches with multiple specialized ministries that can be planned far in advance. I am starting to understand the voices at the last few convention meetings calling for an increased focus and applicability for the small churches.
Rather than LifeWay the For-Profit Megalith donating a few extra dollars to the missions fund, I’d like to see LifeWay the SBC Agency Denominational Publishing House serve the churches of the Southern Baptist Convention by helping churches like mine perform local missions with high-value low-cost outreach and education materials.
It is getting to the point from a cost/benefits perspective where it no longer makes sense to support LifeWay. It is now worth my time to shop around for the best curriculum and best materials for the best price. Problem is, I have generations of people trained to privilege LifeWay out of denominational loyalty. Now, if I want to make changes, I’ve got to train and educate my congregation on why LifeWay no longer delivers value for our stewardship dollars. This puts me into the position of encouraging Cooperative Program style denominational commitment while denigrating an associated agency. I do not have a full complement of lifetime Southern Baptists - our folks come from all over - and this mixed message creates confusion and lowers overall enthusiasm.
I thought there was supposed to be this big LifeWay revolution under Rainer. But the website is still hard to search and navigate, the prices are still high, the kitch is still strong, and the curriculum still draws complaints of biblical insufficiency and non-applicability from my teachers. Perhaps it takes longer than I think to resolve some of this. If so, it would be nice to see some Baptist Press about what is actually going on in Nashville that might give some of us out on the frontier some hope. When the president “co-writes” a book called Simple Church, you might expect his organization to be slightly less byzantine and quite a bit more responsive to the many small congregations whose money it takes and whose denominational name it carries.
Comment by jcyrus
I can see that one has been brewing for a while. I have not seen any changes to Lifeway yet either. We use the SS material and VBS material. It seems that there is probably better material out there, but it is time consuming to wade through it all.
At the T4G conference I picked up a brochure from matthias media. They have a broad range of resources. I haven’t looked at their pricing yet. You may want to check them out as well as others.
“Died-in-the-wool” SBC folks may recognized the difference if you switch material, but for us that would only be a very small group. I understand trying to maintain a sense of denominational loyalty, but that washes both ways, right?
Posted on April 22, 2008 at 10:22 am
Comment by Thad Noyes
Our church Sunday School has been through several of the Matthias Media Pathway Bible Guides. The have been extremely helpful and very well received.
Posted on April 23, 2008 at 7:58 am
Comment by blestou
The website is Matthias Media for anyone else who is interested.
Thanks for the tip guys. I’ll check them out.
Posted on April 25, 2008 at 7:53 am
Comment by Tony Kummer
Brian - Thanks for posting your thoughts on this. At our church, we have been exploring other curriculum publishers for a few years too. Last year we wrote our own VBS and this year we’ve chosen the program from Answers In Genesis.
As for Sunday school we do some Matthias Media “Teaching Little Ones” and several classes use Children’s Desiring God. I’ve heard good things about several other publishers too.
I’m still thankful for LifeWay, but their curriculum doesn’t always meet the education needs of our children.
Posted on May 6, 2008 at 5:39 am
Comment by blestou
Tony,
Thanks for the comment. I’ve also heard some good things about the Desiring God children’s materials.
I am really going to check out Matthias Media. I had never heard of them - then I find out everyone else has…
Writing your own VBS? Yikes!
Peace,
Brian
Posted on May 6, 2008 at 10:11 am
Comment by bob
very brave man you are!!!
Posted on July 28, 2008 at 7:18 am